There must always be a nutritional “bad guy”—a macronutrient or ingredient that is vilified and presented as the main culprit behind bad health outcomes, public fatigue, and chronic disease. Back in the day, it was carbohydrates that bore the brunt of public ire, followed closely by dietary fats, then carbohydrates again in a recurring cycle of dietary demonization. Now, the nutritional zeitgeist has welcomed a brand-new villain to the stage: seed oils, accompanied by the requisite dramatic music and social media hysteria.
The term “seed oils” is typically used as a catch-all for various vegetable oils, such as sunflower, soybean, and canola oil, which are naturally high in polyunsaturated fats. By now, anyone spending even a modest amount of time online has likely encountered a plethora of sensational claims regarding these cooking staples. Critics across various wellness platforms argue that seed oils are essentially poisonous, contending that their consumption is a primary driver of systemic inflammation and virtually every chronic disease known to modern humanity. But is that catastrophic narrative actually supported by the empirical data? Or is this merely another iteration of a cyclical dietary fear-mongering fad that will inevitably fade into obscurity, only to be replaced by a new culinary scapegoat in a matter of months?
As any seasoned observer of nutritional science trends already knows, the answer is remarkably predictable.
As it turns out, seed oils are indeed the absolute worst, and all those internet influencers who claimed so were entirely, 100 percent right!
Just kidding, of course.
A recent umbrella review, which undertook the monumental task of analyzing 48 distinct systematic reviews and meta-analyses, has examined the complex and often misunderstood effects of vegetable oils on multiple critical health outcomes. These outcomes included blood pressure, blood lipids, blood sugar regulation, body weight, the incidence of cardiovascular disease, and various forms of cancer.
When looking closely at the biochemical findings, oils rich in monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats—a category that encompasses many common seed oils—generally improved or, at the very worst, successfully maintained healthy lipid profiles when compared directly to diets higher in saturated fats. For instance, canola oil demonstrated an ability to lower total cholesterol and low-density lipoprotein, commonly known as LDL cholesterol, while maintaining neutral effects on triglycerides and very-low-density lipoproteins. Similarly, rice bran oil showed favorable results by also lowering total cholesterol and LDL.
When turning attention to virgin or extra-virgin olive oil—deserving of a respectful nod to Greece—the data indicated that it consistently lowered total cholesterol, frequently reduced LDL cholesterol, and often raised high-density lipoprotein, or HDL, the cholesterol type traditionally viewed as cardioprotective. On the flip side of the lipid spectrum, tropical oils such as coconut and palm oils consistently raised both total cholesterol and LDL cholesterol. However, they also tended to raise HDL cholesterol as well, a finding that introduces a degree of complexity and somewhat muddies the waters regarding their net cardiovascular impact.
When the scope of the investigation expanded to encompass blood pressure and glycemic control, certain seed oils actually appeared to offer tangible physiological benefits. Flaxseed oil, for example, produced small but meaningful reductions in blood pressure, with a particularly noticeable effect on diastolic pressure. Researchers suggest this positive change may be attributed to its exceptionally high content of alpha-linolenic acid, an essential plant-based omega-3 fatty acid. Sesame oil likewise demonstrated modest reductions in blood pressure alongside noticeable improvements in fasting glucose and long-term glycemic markers like HbA1c in certain observational and experimental contexts. Olive oil and, interestingly, even coconut oil also produced small, positive improvements in some markers of glycemic control.
As the umbrella review turned its focus toward systemic inflammation, cardiovascular events, and the development of cancer, the available data were admittedly more limited, but crucially, they did not suggest any increased risk associated with the consumption of these oils. The exact same conclusion held true for body weight and various measures of body composition, where only extremely small, negligible changes were observed across a handful of studies.
It remains critically important to note, however, that the overall certainty of the available evidence was characterized as mostly low. Furthermore, nutrition researchers point out that oils are rarely, if ever, consumed in complete isolation from other foods. There is also a vast culinary distinction between the oils utilized for routine home cooking and those that are repeatedly heated and reheated to high temperatures, as is frequently the case in many commercial fast-food restaurant deep fryers.
Regardless of these nuances, the robust body of evidence we currently possess by no means supports the alarmist idea that consuming seed oils as part of a balanced, healthy diet will inevitably lead to deleterious health outcomes. In fact, the data indicate that in some instances, their inclusion may even lead to marginal health improvements. As has been repeatedly emphasized by leading nutritional epidemiologists, managing your overall energy intake and making a concerted effort to consume mostly whole, minimally processed foods remains the foundational pillar of good health. Within that broader dietary context, whether an individual chooses to incorporate some seed oils into their routine or avoids them entirely is exceptionally unlikely to make a massive, perceptible difference to their overall health and longevity.
For those interested in staying up to date with the latest developments in physical culture, training methodologies, and nutritional science, the Stronger By Science weekly newsletter delivers practical training tips and concise summaries of the latest research directly to subscribers. Individuals can sign up for the weekly publication entirely free of charge by visiting their official website.
