David Montgomery: The Evolution, Role, and Career Trajectory of an NFL Workhorse

David Montgomery often starts and sets the initial tone for the Detroit offense in a given game, and in games where things are going well, the Lions often turn to him again at the end to close the deal and put the opponent away. The limiting detail is that Montgomery might not do much in between, particularly if the Lions fall behind and decide they need to score quickly with Jahmyr Gibbs. The past two years, the Lions were in advantageous positions often enough for both Montgomery and Gibbs to thrive. As much as Montgomery is dependent on rushing touchdowns for fantasy viability, the touchdowns have consistently been there since he moved from Chicago to Detroit. The loss of offensive coordinator Ben Johnson could change this dynamic for the worse, but head coach Dan Campbell will always focus on power running as a foundation for the Detroit offense. As great as Gibbs is, the Lions still use Montgomery as their primary hammer in the ground game, if only to preserve Gibbs for situations when they really need big yardage.

Few NFL seasons have ever appeared as fluky as Jamaal Williams’ 17-touchdown campaign from 2022, and many understandably figured that the touchdown count was just a product of the time and place rather than a repeatable role for Montgomery to inherit upon leaving Chicago for Detroit in free agency. Unfortunately for the folks who doubted Montgomery—be it due to the concerns of team rushing touchdown regression or the then-shocking 12th overall selection of fellow running back Jahmyr Gibbs—Montgomery proved to be a much better version of what Williams gave the Lions in the same role. Montgomery’s total of 13 touchdowns in 14 games was no fluke, because the Detroit offense is built around a powerful running game behind a dominant offensive line. That offensive line will need to withstand the loss of standout guard Jonah Jackson and the potential retirement of Pro Bowl center Frank Ragnow, though the signing of veteran guard Kevin Zeitler should provide stability. It’s also fair to point out that Montgomery might not get as much of the backfield work in 2024 with Gibbs heading into his second season. Montgomery is a good player who remains the clear lead power runner, but Gibbs is a first-round pick with elite 4.36 speed coming off a rookie year featuring 5.2 yards per carry. We already saw Montgomery’s receiving usage dry up last year with just 16 catches, and it remains possible that more of the rushing load now shifts to Gibbs as well.

The Lions previously took Jamaal Williams and made him the second-leading touchdown scorer in the league during the 2022 season, a direct product of a strong Detroit offensive line, creative playcalling, and the modest talent Williams possessed. Perhaps Montgomery is not necessarily a generational superstar himself, but he brings significantly more overall ability to the field than Williams. It is possible that the other two variables fluctuate—a little bad injury luck can take down an otherwise strong offensive line, and coordinator Ben Johnson might face challenging defensive adjustments that didn’t occur to opponents in 2022—but Montgomery still walks into a remarkably favorable situation. Montgomery and 12th overall pick Jahmyr Gibbs can and must coexist for Detroit to win, because at 199 pounds, Gibbs can only bear so much physical burden over the course of a punishing 17-game season. Short-yardage tasks, which is to often say carries within five yards of the end zone, might be left more so to Montgomery. At over 220 pounds with a hammerhead mentality, Montgomery is built to be a better, more dynamic version of Williams.

Looking back at his career arc, Montgomery’s journey reveals a player who has consistently had to battle shifting circumstances, injuries, and offensive transformations. After a breakthrough 2020 season, Montgomery came roaring out of the gate in 2021 with three touchdowns and two 100-yard rushing performances in the first four weeks. Unfortunately, a sprained knee cost him the next four weeks, and in his absence, backup Khalil Herbert proved nearly as productive as the Bears’ lead back. Montgomery regained his lead role upon his return, but not his momentum, as he ran for only four more touchdowns the rest of the way and didn’t record another 100-yard rushing game. The knee injury may have played a factor in that downturn, as Montgomery’s broken tackle numbers and yards after contact both regressed significantly from the season before, and he does not possess the kind of elite, top-tier athleticism that would allow him to remain fully effective at less than 100 percent health.

Where Montgomery truly excels is with his vision and patience, traits that sometimes leave him at the mercy of a middling offensive line. With the Matt Nagy era coming to an end in Chicago, new offensive coordinator Luke Getsy was expected to bring a Packers-style scheme to the NFC North squad. That transition meant potential for Herbert to earn more touches, but the bigger concern at the time was Montgomery’s shaky team context after the Bears’ six-win 2021 season was followed by an offseason marked by significant personnel losses, including wide receiver Allen Robinson, guard James Daniels, and pass rusher Khalil Mack, without comparable veteran replacements brought in to bridge the gap.

Few players changed the trajectory of their careers for the better in 2020 quite like Montgomery. After a lackluster rookie season that left his future as a potential long-term lead runner in doubt, the 23-year-old got a little more support from his offensive line and a little more trust from coach Matt Nagy, ultimately breaking out for more than 1,000 yards rushing and 1,500 yards from scrimmage. Montgomery’s best assets might be his patience and vision, traits that do leave him more scheme-dependent than some other running backs, though he also possesses plenty of power and finished fourth among all running backs in broken tackles during that campaign. He proved to be a capable receiver and pass protector, more than doubling his production through the air from his debut campaign. The Chicago offense remained a less-than-ideal environment for any skill player, and replacing Mitchell Trubisky with Andy Dalton and Justin Fields did not immediately fix the systemic problems, but Montgomery had established himself alongside Allen Robinson as one of the true centerpieces of the team’s attack. Even if he faced threats to his target share with Damien Williams joining the team and Tarik Cohen working his way back from a major ACL tear, Montgomery remained a safe bet to dominate Chicago’s ground workload.

That workload was hard-earned following a rookie year where Montgomery struggled through a difficult introduction to the professional level, though it was hard to pin the blame solely on him. The Bears’ offense was largely a disaster in 2019, as an injury-plagued offensive line and regression from Mitchell Trubisky constantly put the running game in poor down-and-distance situations and forced Montgomery to dance for yards that simply weren’t there. He finished seventh among qualified rushers in broken tackle rate and tied for sixth in total broken tackles with 28, proving that he was adept at making the first defender miss. The problem was the three or four other defenders who arrived a split second later, as his average of 1.6 yards after contact ranked as the fourth lowest in the league, placing him right alongside Peyton Barber and Sony Michel. Montgomery’s early-down role in tandem with Tarik Cohen seemed secure, but the overall team context remained cloudy. The addition of Bill Lazor as Chicago’s new offensive coordinator was geared toward improving the passing game, as was the trade for Nick Foles to compete with Trubisky under center, while the offensive line looked potentially even worse following the retirement of veteran Kyle Long. Montgomery clearly had the raw skills to be an effective NFL back, but his team context remained suboptimal, and a groin injury from training camp left him questionable heading into his inaugural Week 1 action.

Originally selected as a 2019 third-round pick out of Iowa State, Montgomery stepped into an immediate training camp competition with free-agent signee Mike Davis for a significant role in the Chicago backfield alongside Tarik Cohen. Montgomery’s most impressive traits as a runner have always been his vision, patience, and power, as he calmly lets blocking lanes develop before throttling up to burst through to the second level. While he ran a modest 4.63 seconds in the 40-yard dash at the scouting combine, he showed enough lateral agility to make the initial tackler miss in the hole, generating yards after contact with a stout, compact frame, a low center of gravity, and powerful leg drive. Competent as a receiver and already adept as a pass protector coming out of college, he possessed the requisite skills to stay on the field for all three downs, even if his passing-game targets were inevitably limited by the presence of Cohen. Despite initial concerns regarding his heavy college workload at Iowa State and the physical punishment his aggressive running style naturally creates, Montgomery entered the league as a more versatile version of former bruising backs like Jordan Howard, securing an early-down and short-yardage foundation that would ultimately pave the way for his later success in Detroit.

More From Author

Conor Benn Opens Up About a Traumatic Childhood, Radical Faith, and Rebuilding His Relationship with Father Nigel

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *